DefundCriticalThinking (jockhater2)
★★★★★(5/5)
Jun 22, 2026
This is now the 2nd time I have gotten a Pizza from Marco’s. In my opinion, because competition is so abundant. The people make the difference, not the food.
The employee (male with a wrist brace) shared with me his love for making great tasting pizza.
THATS the difference maker!
I like ordering food from a restaurant the employees ACTUALLY enjoy & like working at.
Tiara Allen
★★★★☆(4/5)
May 1, 2026
I ordered from Marco's Pizza late at night, and overall the experience was pretty good. The food was fresh, hot, and you could tell the ingredients were quality. My all-meat calzone tasted great, but it was missing the bacon, which was a little disappointing. Other than that, everything else was on point. The DoorDash driver was also very nice. Considering it was a late-night order, they did a really solid job. I’d order again, just hoping everything is included next time!
M H
★★★★★(5/5)
Apr 17, 2026
Super impressed! Our company ordered $400.00 in pizzas. This establishment crushed it out with one employee making the ZaZa. Also on the spot and no notice in advance due to another pizza place canceling our order. The other company had 2 days notice and couldn't complete what Marcos could with short notice and one employee.
Regena Slaten
★★★☆☆(3/5)
Mar 26, 2026
Yesterday was quite an experience so I use the Grubhub app to order a large pizza. I did a little bit extra. I got the honey hot added, and then I ordered brownies for children and myself this is our typical order. We usually order Marcos from the good Hope location once or twice a month. If it’s a very busy month then it’ll be three times so I placed the order at 7:36. It said that my order will be delivered to me around 805 to 815 around 810 is when the mess begin. I will receive a call from Marco’s, you could not hear it. It was dead air so I hung up in a few minutes later I called back. The guy said hey my delivery driver was out by your house and there was an issue delivering the pizza. The person at the house said that there was no one there that ordered at pizza. I told him that I have been sitting in my living room where my front porch is with the windows open and music playing. I also have a camera doorbell. No one came to my home. He said no worries. It must’ve been a delivery issue, but we’ll get the pizza To you. roughly around 30 to 40 minutes later, I still hadn’t received the pizza so I called Marco’s again. I was then placed on hold. I got the manager. The phone call was very distorted, but I was able to make out What he said and he basically just said that oh well the delivery driver went home for the evening. He said that he went out, but he couldn’t deliver the pizza so we’re just waiting for a Grubhub driver. He said it’ll be another 20 minutes as that To make the order fresh for me, I said OK you know this is my kids dinner. We just really wanted to have the food and in our night so about 20 minutes later still no pizza I called. They said the delivery driver would be 12 minutes out. Grubhub about this whole ordeal and they said that my order was set for self delivery or customer pick up which I never agreed to pick the pizza up at this point. I’m kind of steaming so I called Grubhub and they said well they said that the food So it’s been over hour. We’re gonna just cancel your order. I told them no I don’t want my order canceled. I would like to have the pizza. We’ve already waited for so long and you know we just want the food. I didn’t want to wait 3 to 5 days for a It just was too much I would just rather have the pizza so I then head to the good location and the manager he was just like yeah I remember the pizza should’ve been delivered and I said no if the pizza was delivered would I be here? he was like yeah I agree he was pleasant He ended up making me the pizza and the brownie unfortunately, the pizza was not exactly how I ordered it, but he did upgrade to an extra large however, just the whole ordeal was a very lot to deal with for the delivery driver to lie and say that At my house and clearly he hadn’t been then for the Grubhub driver to then take the second pizza. It just resulted in a very long night for me. The manager did make the overall experience a little bit better being so nice to talk to and accommodating, however, it was one pizza one brownie. I’m about 10 minutes from the location. They should’ve never happened and it’s really unfortunate because I’m not sure if I’m going to continue to order from Marco’s. They do have some of the better pizza in the Milwaukee area, but This experience just made me doubt whether they would be reliable in the future
Randy
★★★★☆(4/5)
Dec 31, 2025
We had the supreme and cheese steak pizza at work from this location and it was so good that I went and got more after work. The employees were ok but could definitely be more enthusiastic, energetic and attentive when it comes to their customer service skills that’s what keeps customers coming back.
Carolyn Williams
★★★★★(5/5)
Jun 12, 2025
I started ordering pizza from Marco's back in February, I think. I didn't know anyone who had order or even eaten from here. I wanted pizza and my regular place was running 2 hours behind. I ordered, I chose to pick it up and it was nice and hot and my goodness it was good! They even gave me percentages off my order even though I had no coupons. So I have been ordering here since. I friends and family likes it, so I'm sold. Thanks Marco's Pizza!