Megan Elliott
★★★★★(5/5)
Dec 18, 2025
I live exactly in the middle of both locations. The level of service at this one is like night and day difference compared to the new Albany location. The employess have a high level of professionalism. My order has never been incorrect at this one. Ive always received all the sauces I ordered, without having to go back for them. And ive never gotten a phone call 5 mins later saying they're out of the thin crust i ordered and my only option is to get regular crust bc i had used a reward. If you have a choice, definitely choose the jeffersonville location. And the specialty cheese pizza is awesome, especially considering im usually a ton of toppings person.
Roman Sanchez
★★★★☆(4/5)
Jan 13, 2026
shoutout to the girl that made the pizza she was working alone i assume she made a picture perfect pizza
Jack Stepro
★★★☆☆(3/5)
Dec 5, 2025
Pizza had a bacon flavor. Maybe Sausage was too spicy or the ham was the cause. Usually those taste ok. Bacon flavor is not for me.
Elvis Dizdar
★★★★★(5/5)
Apr 28, 2024
So I don't know why this place is 3.5 stars cuz it deserves 25 STARS✨. My family and I always go for the usual pizza chains around. This time we decided to do something different, try something new. We felt that for a perfect movie night we will have Marco's Pizza 🍕. We placed an online order and got a discount on our order. 2 pizzas, bread sticks, and wings. I immediately got a confirmation email and my order was being prepared. It said it will be ready at 9:03pm. The order was ready at 9pm. Swift and perfect no waiting no disappointment. Drove back home and the fun began. Everything was absolutely delicious. I prefer Marco's Pizza over papa js and others. Their wings ware amazing better than most around. All in all zero disappointment and 💯 percent satisfaction. It was all destroyed with pleasure. We will definitely be back for more Marco's. Guys give Marco's a try you won't be disappointed. Every place when they start up has their ups and downs until they get it right. They are and Marco's Pizza has got it right. Bloody delicious 😋. Now what u guys waiting for go and get you some Marco's.
Chloe Turner
★★★☆☆(3/5)
Feb 21, 2024
drove by and saw a new pizza place. rec’d coupon flyer in the mail. about same price or maybe high than competitors. went to store and ordered. Looked like eight employees in the kitchen although the process seemed real slow for preparing and baking products. I probably waited a good twenty minutes or so. I saw a male manager continuously tossing the raw pizza dough on his arms to form shape. that was a turn off. I asked another manager and he said that was Marcos way and arms are washed before tossing duties. I got the pizza and breadsticks home. We ate. Breadsticks are long and hollow and got cold quick. The pizza recipe was close to Dominos. I will stick to Dominos.
