Katie Fishack
★★★★★(5/5)
Nov 15, 2025
If I could give this place a million stars I would. The hot honey pizza better never get taken off the menu. It is an orgasm in your mouth.
Also the staff is super friendly. Don’t mind the 1 star reviews because most of them are just people looking for a reason to complain about something.
Joshua's Journey
★★★★☆(4/5)
Feb 7, 2026
That was Dam good pizza!!! I think you guys may have just stolen my business from piezanos. Quality ingredients that aren't skimped on. Got the crust crispy how i wanted. I'll definitely be back.
Tiffany Warner
★★★★★(5/5)
Sep 9, 2025
We order from Marco’s all the time and they always hit the spot! The staff here go above and beyond. While I was waiting for my pizza, the gentleman making it even remembered that I usually like it well done. The new app didn’t give me that option, but he took the time to ask and then put my pizza back in the oven for a few more minutes just the way I like it. It’s those thoughtful little details that make this Marco’s so special and why we keep coming back. Thank you for always being so considerate and making sure our food is perfect!
Kevin DeFord
★★★★☆(4/5)
Dec 7, 2023
Hey, I’m not sure if this email will find anyone but I have a small concern.
I’ve ordered 4 or 5 times and the pizza is really good…. But tonight I feel like the ball was dropped. I ordered half veggie and half meat and it looks like they just put the bare minimum of toppings on the meat side.
The in house employees were all very busy and by the time I realized the pizza was “skimpy” I was already home.
Please let me know what can be done to fix this.
I’m not a fan of public reviews so
I tried to find a management email address online but I had no luck
Juliea Birkey
★★★★☆(4/5)
Sep 16, 2023
Stopped in for lunch, clean dining room. Pizza was good but had to deal with the crew talking about car accidents and getting tickets. They were loud and really didn’t care about the diners Only two tables in dining room.
amy aitapata
★★★★★(5/5)
Mar 21, 2023
My dining companion recently moved from up north where there are many more Marco's, and she was very excited that one was coming to St. Augustine.
We were greeted as soon as we came in and staff were quick and patient as we placed our order. While there are two tables inside, they're more of the sit-and-wait-for-takeout tables than dine-in tables.
The pizza was great! Excellent, excellent crust and great toppings. Unfortunately, according to the app they don't deliver to the Shores, so for us east of US1, it looks like it's carry out only. That stretch of 207 is not fun to cross without a light, so plan your route.
